No Bake Peanut Butter Desserts – 23 Best Dessert Recipes EVER (says my hubby!)
Love easy no bake desserts? Me too! Love peanut butter? So does my hubby! Below are 23 quick simple no bake peanut butter desserts.
From healthy to decadent, from few ingredients and gluten-free… so many yummy desserts with peanut butter to choose from!
My hubby loves… and I mean, L-O-V-E-S peanut butter pie. In fact, he loves all desserts, cookies, candy and sweet treats that have peanut butter in them.
While he’s not getting tired of my same ol same ol’ peanut butter pie, I am – I want something new to make with peanut butter to change things up a bit.
And wowzers, did I find some wonderful and drool-worthy recipes to try!
I even found some healthy peanut butter desserts, gluten-free and low calorie options too (but let’s be honest, that is NOT what the man wants haha!)
But I might be able to sneak them in here and there – ya know, when he starts mumbling about his pants “shrinking” in the dryer (hmmmm….)
Here’s the things I was looking for in the no bake desserts…
Must contain peanut butter (of course)
Must be easy enough that even *I* can make them
Don’t require way-too-crazy ingredients or things I’ve never heard of
Recipe needs to be yummy and pretty enough to take to potlucks or serve to guests
The recipe picture must make me drool haha!
Also wanted some holiday desserts for Fall, Thanksgiving, Christmas, Easter etc
I found some really great recipes for no bake peanut butter desserts below that are all absolute keepers!
Many thanks to all the food bloggers that created the recipes below!
While you didn’t ask to be featured here, I sure appreciate all your hard work and VERY creative recipes!
No Bake Peanut Butter Desserts
SO many yummy and simple no bake peanut butter desserts to choose from!
Which one will YOU pick?
Mercy these are good!!!! I made them last night and we just ate them for an office birthday! So easy to make too. And the parchment paper…. Brilliant idea.
Beware tho… They are RICH!!!! A small piece goes a long way! I was worried I was cutting them into too small of pieces, but they could have been smaller!!
Definitely will make these again…. And again…. And again!
I’ve made this no bake Reese cup pie about 3 times now… It is addictive. Everyone who tastes this wants the recipe and rave and rave about it. I made it again for this weekend for our family reunion.
I love this pie! Butterfingers are one the hubby's favorite indulgences, it was SUPER easy and loved not using Cool Whip too!
So easy! I read the recipe, hopped into the kitchen, and put this together in like 5 minutes! OMG! YUM!
This was sooo good! Everyone at potluck raved over this! I will make again I am sure and might do chocolate drizzle over the nutter butters and maybe another time use chocolate pudding.
This was so good! Perfect dessert to make on busy weeknights! The kids loved it!
With irresistible Reese’s cups and Oreos as key ingredients, I was already certain that I’d love this dessert and it didn’t disappoint! Everyone loved it, there wasn’t a single piece left!
No Bake Peanut Butter Treats are soft, chewy bites sure to satisfy that sweet tooth! Just 5 ingredients and 15 minutes needed for these tasty treats!
Love this recipe, I have made it twice already and it has been a hit at both gatherings I took them too!
This was the first recipe I learned to make in Home Economics 40+ years ago… they are and will always be one of my favorites!
These were so so good! They tasted like a big Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup! Will definitely be making these again, and probably be doubling the batch!
Even after making using some of the time-saving shortcuts, this recipe was a total hit. Everyone had seconds! The peanut butter crumblies are top notch!!
Added some sprinkles on top of this peanut butter lasagna and it turned out so very yummy!
A dinner guest at our house the other week is gluten-free and I wanted to make dessert. The bars were a big hit and delicious. Literally, EVERYONE loved them!
OH MY GOSH. Banana cream pie is my fave, and peanut butter is his…may have to make this for our anniversary!
This was excellent! I put sliced strawberries on top instead of cherries and chopped peanuts instead of walnuts. Turned out great!
I made this for my relative's birthday and he loved it! I’m not a huge peanut butter fan but even I had seconds. I followed the recipe exactly and it delivered! He felt very special and the triffle looked beautiful. Talk about effortless decadence. Not exactly "no bake" but darn close enough!
Sweet candy corn peanut bars are creamy, salty and sweet all wrapped up into a no bake bar. This easy to make bar is a delicious dessert that’s perfect for fall, and is full of marshmallows, peanut butter, candy corn and butterscotch!
I am not the best baker and let me tell you this recipe was so easy and these cookies are insane! They are DELICIOUS and taste just like the expensive Crumbl store cookies!
These no bake chocolate peanut butter cookies are thick, fudgy, and need just 4 ingredients. Deceptively healthy, they literally melt in your mouth!
You only need 5 ingredients to make no bake peanut butter balls. The bite-sized treats are perfect for gifting this holiday season. This family favorite recipe is quick and easy!
These No-Bake Chocolate Peanut Butter Cheesecake Bars have a peanut date crust and a super creamy cashew-based peanut butter filling – you’d never guess that they’re vegan, gluten free, and refined sugar free!
These No Bake Christmas Peanut Butter Ritz Crackers are one of my family’s favorite no bake treats. Buttery Ritz crackers, creamy peanut butter, almond bark and sprinkles, is all you need to make these delicious Christmas “cookies”.
