Matt Cutts Debunked Me

So tonight I am minding my own business and sitting on Twitter trying to catch up on some cool Tweets and industry info. Suddenly a tweet from Matt Cutts to ME pops up on my stream. (In case you don’t know, Matt Cutts is the head of web spam at Google). He let me know that he left a comment on my Google Quality Raters post to clear up a misconception. It was something *I* said in my post – and yep, he totally debunked me…lol! Hey, when you’re wrong, you’re wrong – so I want to clarify and stand corrected. Here’s what Matt Cutts clarified for me.

In that post about Google Quality Raters I was quoting pieces of an interview with Scott Huffman (Google’s Engineering Director). Mr Huffman was asked if ONE Quality Rater can affect the rankings of a url. Mr Huffman said No (in more words than that, but “No” is the gist of it).

I then went on with my post and *I* said:

“Now this makes sense to me – ONE rater can not cause a rankings change. However, I do believe that if a certain percentage of raters mark one url as spam or non-relevant, that it does throw up some type of flag in the system that can cause something to happen to that url. Now I naturally do not KNOW this, but I get that sneaky feeling.”

According to Matt Cutts, my “sneaky feeling” is wrong.

This is the comment Matt left in the comments:



So- there it is – according to Matt, I am wrong (well, my “sneaky feeling” is wrong).

Quality Raters can not directly change the ranking of a url.

All they do is is review potential rankings caused by a test algorithm change. Based on their feedback (ie, their ratings), Google can tell if the test algo makes things “better” or “worse” in the SERPs. If it is deemed “better”, that test algo is released out into the Google Sandbox where a small percentage of live Google traffic gets the test algo results.

If that sample of live traffic shows that the search results are “better”, then the algo is released out to all of us.

And THEN your rankings could very well change.



That’s the short version from how I understand it. If you want to understand the complete process of this, read this post: How Google Makes Algorithm Changes

So, let’s continue the story…

So Matt Cutts (@mattcutts) tweets to me (@potpiegirl) that he left a comment on my blog.

I thank him and then ask him a question:

“Would multiple spam ratings cause an internal Google employee to manually review that url?”

To me, that makes sense. If many HUMAN reviewers all flag a site as spam, wouldn’t it make sense that someone internal with Google would check that url out?

His answer to me was short and sweet.

Here’s the entire Twitter conversation:



Naturally, his comment on my blog here at PotPieGirl.com sparked more questions from others on Twitter.

Here’s some more Q&A regarding his comment about Google’s Quality Raters and Google rankings:





Which amusingly led to Matt Cutts making a “note to self” (uhhhh… a “tweet” to self? lol!)



Nice to have a video about all this – or at least something about all this – thanks, Matt! And thanks for taking the time to stop by and “debunk” me 🙂

I will say this – it does make sense to me that the data gathered from the human Quality Raters should not be “mucked” with. If you go in and start manually changing things, you don’t really know if the algo ever gets better or worse.

Edited to add: Matt came back to answer some questions others were asking him the comments area of my post.

Here is more from Matt:



So, there you have it…

What do YOU think?

Would You Like a

FREE Copy Of My

Blog Post Mechanic Guide?

($19.99 value)

 

If you’ve ever had a blog post that seemed to be doing well and moving up the ranks in Google only to see if stall out and STOP improving, you will LOVE this guide.

This guide contains 5 unique and simple steps to improve a stalled, or totally broken down, blog post.

 

Also very helpful for posts that never ranked or made sales at all.

 

Learning to be a Blog Post Mechanic will be one of the most important ranking/blogging skills you will learn.

Just enter your email below and I will send you this guide for free.

 

 

blog-post-mechanic-ppg-cover

Success! Now head on over to your inbox to click to confirm your email so I can send your free Blog Post Mechanic Bonus Guide to your right now =)

53 Comments

  1. Tim Burns December 7, 2011
    • Interested Party December 7, 2011
  2. Duy Nguyen December 7, 2011
    • PotPieGirl December 7, 2011
      • Interested Party December 7, 2011
        • PotPieGirl December 8, 2011
  3. James Hussey December 7, 2011
    • PotPieGirl December 7, 2011
  4. steve December 7, 2011
    • Matt Cutts December 7, 2011
      • PotPieGirl December 7, 2011
      • James Hussey December 7, 2011
      • Interested Party December 7, 2011
      • marianne December 8, 2011
      • H8 Spinsters December 9, 2011
      • Cody Baird December 14, 2011
  5. John December 7, 2011
  6. Gary December 7, 2011
  7. Carey Baird December 7, 2011
  8. Charles December 7, 2011
    • PotPieGirl December 8, 2011
    • Hendrik December 26, 2011
  9. Mister_Papagiorgio December 7, 2011
  10. Karen December 7, 2011
  11. John Blakemore December 7, 2011
  12. Scott December 7, 2011
    • Interested Party December 7, 2011
    • PotPieGirl December 8, 2011
      • H8 Spinsters December 9, 2011
  13. Onefineham December 7, 2011
    • Deane December 7, 2011
    • PotPieGirl December 8, 2011
  14. Jim December 7, 2011
    • PotPieGirl December 8, 2011
  15. Nick Heuer December 7, 2011
    • Onefineham December 7, 2011
  16. Daniel December 7, 2011
  17. Leo Saraceni December 7, 2011
    • James Hussey December 7, 2011
  18. Justin December 7, 2011
  19. Dustin Woodard December 7, 2011
  20. john andrews December 7, 2011
  21. I'm the Queen of England December 7, 2011
    • PotPieGirl December 8, 2011
  22. Mike December 8, 2011
  23. A. Marc December 8, 2011
  24. Atul Bansal December 10, 2011
  25. Bengo December 10, 2011
  26. Karl December 13, 2011
  27. Erin December 16, 2011
  28. Nicholas Massey December 16, 2011
  29. Joe B December 25, 2011
blog-post-mechanic-ppg-cover

Can I Send You a FREE PotPieGirl Bonus Guide?

If you’ve ever had a blog post that seemed to be doing well and moving up the ranks in Google only to see if stall out and STOP improving, you will LOVE this guide.

This guide contains 5 unique and simple steps to improve a stalled, or totally broken down, blog post.

Also very helpful for posts that never ranked or made sales at all.

Learning to be a Blog Post Mechanic will be one of the most important ranking/blogging skills you will learn.

Just enter your email below and I will send you this guide for free (a $19.99 value)

 

 

Success! Now head on over to your inbox to click to confirm your email so I can send your free Blog Post Mechanic Bonus Guide to your right now =)