14 Comments

  1. What I want to know is; will *I* learn anything from this eBook? I generally avoid buying eBooks, and sales letters really put me off, but maybe just this once I’ll give it a try.

    Maybe.

    thefluffanuttas last blog post..New Tools for Squidoo Lensmasters

  2. Hi Jennifer,

    Karl here, the author of ‘Secret Cash Machine on Squidoo’.

    Thankyou for the well formed and balanced review!

    Oddly enough, I was looking at the list of customers and the username ‘Potpiegirl’ popped out of the page. I thought to myself… ‘where do I know that name from’.

    I even asked my cat, Elvis, who just replied with ‘meow meowwww’. Which I think meant ‘Search Google’, but it could also have meant ‘FEED ME’…lol

    So after feeding him, I searched google for potpiegirl and the minute I saw your pic, I remembered. Your one of the biggest users of Squidoo and have some great lenses.

    I am so glad you got a copy and found some things that where useful to you. Maybe I can use some of your words for a nice testimonial.

    If you need it, I also have some banners you can use for this review page.

    Again, thank you for taking the time to read the book and write your kind review.

    Karl Pemberton
    Author of ‘The Secret Cash Machine on Squidoo’

  3. Funny. I just ran across this because Karl left a comment on one of my gajillion blogs. But the sales page just really was a turn off for me. They always are. I’m just not the kind of person who responds to a used car salesman pitch. (And from what you said about the book, none of the people who actually could use the book would. Bummer for Karl.) Like fluff, I shall ponder whether it’s worth it. I have a hard time paying that much for a physical book where I know there were materials required that I’m paying for. Not sure about an ebook. I _might_ have been convinced if there was a single link to any of his lenses. I’m just so darn suspicious and cynical. It’s the part of me that’s still a reporter. Appreciate you taking the time to do the review, though.

  4. Your review is pretty interesting and looks like the book might be a good read. I look forward to getting your bonuses which I hope will take me to the next level. Because right now, I could use a lot of help with my lenses.
    Jenn Thomas
    Muvar Software

  5. Hi Susan,

    Like you I hate hype… but, sadly its all part of good marketing. Those that have read the book have emailed me their positive views and thanks. Their satisfaction means a great deal to me and I am already seeing some great lenses they have shown me as a result of reading the book.

    However, if anyone wants to write a review and bypass my sales page I can make that happen.

    Karl

  6. See, I do marketing for a living and hype doesn’t enter into it. That’s sales. πŸ™‚

    That said, I’d be happy to do a review. Send me a chapter, any chapter, and I’ll take a look. (You could do the same for thefluffanutta as well if you want to convince him to get on the bandwagon. He has a broader audience than I do.) If I think based on that that the book’s worth buying, I’ll do so and do a post on my blog about it, as well as a more complete review. If I think it’s OK, but probably not going to tell me anything I don’t already know, I’ll do a post saying so and not buy the book. If I think it’s wretched and want to warn people not to waste their money, I’ll say that. Fair enough? πŸ™‚ You can contact me through my blog or via any of my lenses.

    (Jennifer, sorry to hijack the comments. πŸ™‚

  7. First off – Karl, Welcome to PotPieGirl.com! I am so glad you stopped by! Fluff and Susan are kick-butt lensmasters – get them a chapter to review.

    Susan, sweetie… you’re hijacking my comments? Uh, no way, kiddo! I have been making a LOT of lenses today and haven’t even come near this blog. Karl’s book lit a fire under me =)

    Keep up the conversation – I love it!!

    Jenn, thanks for reading! I hope you enjoy Karls book as much as I did!

    As for the ‘hype’ thing….

    Yes, I was a bit turned off by the ‘hype factor’ of the info page. However, Squidoo is one of the things I do that is important to my online business. If there is new information out there – or even a different view-point, I want to read it. Hype or no hype.

    Squidoo is getting SO competitive… we need all the edge we can get.

    The book itself was NOT hypey and it was very respectful to the Squidoo site, staff, and community. Heck, we can drop more than the cost of the ebook on one dinner out, so my thinking is, why WOULDN’T I purchase this Squidoo guide? If I learned even ONE new thing, it would be more than I would learn eating out =)

    I only came up with ten things that I wish were in the book, so I made a separate bonus for those that buy thru my link. Those that have received the ten bonus tips are very happy with them.. guess I should have made my own little advanced Squidoo tips book…haha!

    I’m so glad all of you are here… keep on chatting, I’ve got lenses to make!

    Best to all of you!

    Jennifer

  8. Just bought the book and I absolutely love it. I was going to spend so much time going through everything on Squidoo but it was going to take just so much time. Cool stuff!

    I was wondering how you go about asking for review copies of things? I don’t have a ton of money to spend on products but I love to review things since I think I have a good perspective. How do I set myself up as someone who is (and I hate to say this word) “worthy” of reviewing something?

  9. Hi Carter,

    Let me take a quick min to answer you.

    I wrote an email to all those customers that requested ebook updates and in that email you will find some pointers.

    If you got that email and still have questions, please let me know.

    I am also sure Jennifer will be more than happy to help you out.

    Karl

  10. PotPieGirl says:

    @ Carter –

    I don’t usually ask directly for a review copy (or a preview chapter). Usually, if I am considering a product for promotion, I have questions about it. I will want to know what experience level the product is designed for, if it involves PPC (or requires any other investments in order to work) and other similiar questions.

    I will then email the author and ask my questions – but I do not ask for a review copy. Most product owners will do a little checking up on me and then freely offer a sample chapter (at the least).

    However, I leave it up the content owner to OFFER.

    Just my two cents

    Jennifer

  11. Can I add a couple more coins to the pot?

    For sure, I get sent some products to review even without asking. Not only digital, but also physical books. I think it has something to do with being around this internet for sooooo long πŸ™‚

    Whilst I dont mind giving people in the industry a review copy, I cannot tell you how much more it means to have someone from the industry buy a copy. For them then to write a review, shows that they are serious about promoting and are in a position to help the people who buy via their link.

    Keep in mind people may give a bad review!

    So with that in mind, you can imagine the business relationship that can happen if you buy the product and give a measured review.

  12. PotPieGirl says:

    Karl –

    VERY well said and an excellent point to make.

    It is important to me that my readers trust me. Working on the internet makes ‘trust’ difficult to earn – sometimes it all seems to impersonal, ya know?

    However, if I say “I BOUGHT this, I READ this, I USED this…and these are MY results”, you can take it to the bank that it is the truth.

    Bottom line is, I cannot truly review a product, or give genuine feedback, if I am not reviewing it from the CONSUMERS view-point.

    Jennifer

  13. Hi! I was surfing and found your blog post… nice! I love your blog. πŸ™‚ Cheers! Sandra. R.

Comments are closed.